Trust in management is falling

PwC's Global Workforce Hopes and Fears Survey 2026, published in September, covered 49,364 workers across 48 countries. Trust in management fell seven percentage points in a year, and fewer than half of workers now trust top management.

The drop isn’t spread evenly. Among what PwC calls the engine room, the 56% of respondents who do most of the day-to-day work, only 40% trust their immediate manager and 33% trust top management. Among the group PwC calls front-runners, 82% trust their immediate manager and 75% trust top management.

That gap matters because the engine room does most of the work. It carries out every reorganization and every technology rollout, and it's the group least inclined to trust the people asking for the change.

Why managers carry most of the weight

Gallup's State of the Global Workplace 2025 report attributes 70% of the variance in team engagement to the manager. In the same report, only 44% of managers worldwide said they had received any management training.

Doctoral research by Sovera founder Dr. Annie Graziani at the University of Pennsylvania points the same way. She interviewed 35 working parents at U.S. organizations with 500 or more employees, and 25 of them rated six workplace supports on importance and effectiveness. Supportive management received near-unanimous importance ratings, 4.90 out of 5. It was also the best-delivered support of the six, at 4.05, and it still fell short.

The spread in those ratings is the useful part. Parents agreed closely on how much good management matters, and their effectiveness ratings varied far more. The dissertation describes manager support as both the most important variable and the most variable one. An organization that leaves it to individual discretion has built a system that depends on whoever happens to hold the role.

What a lack of trust in the workplace looks like

Low trust tends to show up in management habits that read as diligence from the top and as suspicion from below. Common signs of micromanagement include:

  • Approval required for ordinary decisions the person is already accountable for

  • Frequent status check-ins that duplicate information already available

  • Performance judged by visible activity, hours online or response time, instead of results

  • Work redone or heavily revised without a clear standard that was missed

  • Information held back until a manager decides it's needed

Each of these tells an employee the same thing: the organization isn't sure they can do the job. Over time, people respond by doing exactly what's asked and little more.

Perception adds to the problem. The American Management Association's research on the manager-employee disconnect found 59% of managers said their own engagement rose over the past year, while 80% of employees said their manager's engagement had stalled or declined. Managers and their teams are often describing two different workplaces.

How to stop micromanaging and build leadership trust

Trust-centered leadership comes down to a few habits most managers can learn.

Define the outcome before the method. Teams trust managers who are specific about what a good result looks like and leave the route to the people doing the work. Vague goals invite checking, because neither side knows when the job is done.

Replace oversight with accountability. Agree on a result, a date and a way to review it, then let the person get on with the work. Pick one recurring check-in and ask whether a clear outcome definition would make it unnecessary.

Measure outcomes in performance reviews. If reviews reward visible effort, managers learn to monitor. Review criteria tied to documented outcomes give managers a reason to stop.

Ask the trust question directly. Ask managers what they would do differently if they assumed their team was trustworthy by default. The answer shows the operating assumption a leadership layer is running on.

Train managers on purpose. With fewer than half of managers trained, most organizations are relying on whoever was promoted to figure it out. Manager development works best when it's part of the organization's structure, with its own time and budget.

Trust, managers and employee engagement

Gallup’s research has linked managers and employee engagement for years, and the 2025 report puts the manager’s share of team engagement variance at 70%. The managers people stay for tend to be clear about expectations, steady in follow-through and willing to get out of the way. The managers people leave tend to check constantly and judge effort by how visible it is.

For leadership teams, that turns trust into something measurable. It can be tracked in how managers spend their time, what review processes reward, and whether employees say their manager makes their work easier or harder.

Frequently asked questions

What builds trust in the workplace?
Clear expectations, consistent follow-through and autonomy in how work gets done. Gallup attributes 70% of the variance in team engagement to the manager, which makes manager behavior the largest single lever most organizations have.

What are the signs of micromanagement?
Approval required for routine decisions, repeated status updates, performance judged by visible activity instead of results, and work redone without a clear standard. Each one signals doubt about an employee's ability to do the job.

How does a lack of trust affect employees?
Low trust tends to reduce discretionary effort, as people do what is required and stop volunteering ideas or extra work. PwC’s 2026 survey found trust in management fell seven points in a year, and only 40% of what PwC calls the engine room trust their immediate manager.

How can managers stop micromanaging?
Define the outcome before the method, replace routine check-ins with agreed results and review dates, and make sure performance reviews reward documented outcomes instead of visible effort.

Can leadership trust be trained?
Yes. Gallup found only 44% of managers worldwide have received any management training, so most organizations have room to build this skill deliberately instead of hoping it develops on its own.

Sovera helps leadership teams measure how people actually experience work and build the manager capability to act on it. Learn more at soverastrategy.com.

Sources: PwC, Global Workforce Hopes and Fears Survey 2026 (September 2026), Gallup, State of the Global Workplace 2025 (April 2025), American Management Association, The Manager-Employee Disconnect on Engagement and Effectiveness (October 14, 2025), Graziani, A. (2026). Working Parents as Experts: Evaluating Organizational Supports for Work–Life Integration in Postpandemic Workplace Settings. University of Pennsylvania., Graziani, A. (2026). [SSRN paper title]. SSRN. https://ssrn.com/abstract=7441738
Next
Next

The Cost of Employee Turnover: What Each Exit Really Costs